Reconciling Conversations

The Reconciling Conversations Group is part of a growing group of United Methodist individuals, congregations, campus ministries, and other groups working for the full participation of all people--including lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered people--in the life of the life and ministry of the church.

Tuesday, September 30, 2014

Carl Johnson: A Church Grows Stronger

The primary reason for my involvement with Reconciling Conversations is that I was personally invited to participate. As is true with most things in life, however, the more fully explained reason is more complex.
There are two facets that formed my perspective. Since my early young adult days, I have had close friends who were gay and lesbian. Neither did I consider them any different, nor did I care for them any less, than I did my straight friends. They were simply my friends.
The more formative situation—the one that forced my hand at making a conscious decision and publicly taking a stand—began eight years ago, in July of 2006. While I was serving as senior minister of a church in Asheville, the Director of Music Ministries, who had been employed by that congregation for over 20 years, asked if he and his wife could come by the parsonage on a Sunday afternoon. As they sat on the couch holding hands, they shared with me that he was gay. A gentle, kind, and very devout man, Steve had known for some time, but finally accepted that he could not live a truly fulfilled—and faithful—life if he continued to hide such an important part of who he is.
He also shared with me that he would like to make his proclamation publicly. We had several more conversations before deciding that the next step should be to share his decision to come out with the Chair of the Staff Parish Relations Committee and then with the full committee.
The process that evolved over the next year was complex, but I have never been more proud of a community of faith! Simply put, after many meetings and much conversation, both the Staff Parish Relations Committee and the Administrative Council unanimously and publicly supported Steve and expressed their strong commitment to his continuing his professional role at the church. They did so knowing that there would be repercussions, and as it happened, a significant number of families did leave the church, and the church budget took a big hit. But the church defined itself as being faithful to the teachings of Christ and proclaimed itself as a congregation where “all people are welcome.”

While the church struggled in the first years, I believed then, and it is now proving to be true, that the church would grow stronger over time and that it would find itself being much more faithful to the Gospel of Christ.